Introduction Last year’s decision of the Employment Tribunal in Scott v Walker Morris LLP sheds light on steps that LLPs and partnerships ought to be taking in relation to their retirement provisions and how they deal with partners or LLP members (all referred to in this article as “partners”) who do not wish to retire….
The recent case of Cobden v Cobden [2024] explores the jurisdiction of the court in a partnership dissolution to permit one partner to buy out the other, rather than ordering a sale of partnership assets and division of the proceeds. The judgment contains a comprehensive review of the law relating to Syers orders, including in…
Partnership dissolution is often misunderstood, not only as to what it entails, but also as to what the outcomes may be. When partners seek to “weaponise” the dissolution of a partnership, as a means of taking a business forward, while leaving one of the partners behind/excluding him from further participation, further important considerations arise.
Losses resulting from expulsion following whistleblowing can be very substantial, and there is no statutory limit on the amount of compensation that can be awarded.
But in some cases the expulsion of the whistleblower may:
In such circumstances it may be argued by the continuing LLP members that the chain of causation between the whistleblowing and the whistleblower’s loss brought about by the expulsion of the whistleblower has been broken, and that accordingly no recoverable loss arises.
The Court of Appeal decision earlier this year in Wilsons Solicitors & others v Roberts brings such scenarios sharply back into focus.
An LLP member or company shareholder:
may in some circumstances be able to pursue a claim against his co-proprietors on behalf of the LLP or company (even though the LLP or company is otherwise controlled by the misbehaving majority), in order to seize back the assets and/or to recover compensation for the LLP or company. Furthermore the LLP or company might well be ordered, at the outset of the claim, and throughout the conduct of the claim, to pay most of the member/shareholder’s legal costs incurred in bringing the claim.
(This article was first published on the Kluwer Mediation Blog on 7 March 2017)
…the typical all-powerful and largely irreplaceable partner of yore has evolved to become a powerless, placeholder partner, keeping the chair warm for the next incumbent of his post. He is the counterpoint to, and the prey of, the predator partner.
This has radically altered how many partnership disputes, especially in the professions, tend to arise and are resolved.
The case of Campbell v Campbell [2017] serves as a prime example of the need for business partners trading through any type of business vehicle to record the precise terms of their business relationship with one another at the outset. It is also a good illustration of a WATNA (worst alternative to a negotiated agreement)….
I previously reported on the case of Moore v Moore (2016), in which the court ordered, based on proprietary estoppel, that a farmer’s son was entitled to take over his father’s interest in the family farming partnership, despite the fact that the father wanted to leave his interest to another family member in his will….
In the case of Hosking v Marathon Asset Management LLP [2016] EWHC 2418 (Ch) the court had to answer the question, “Whether the share of profits of a partner of a partnership or a member of an LLP, paid out pursuant to and in accordance with a partnership or LLP deed, can be subject to…
“…the father and son fell out, and the father decided to disinherit his son…” A share in a partnership is easy to transfer. It can be transferred by signature of a very short document. It can even be transferred by oral agreement. The assets so transferred can include land, without the usual complex formalities associated…
In Re Newtons Coaches Ltd ([2016] EWHC 3068 (Ch), 29 November 2016) useful guidance has been given by Mr Registrar Jones in the Companies Court as to whether partners of an insolvent partnership may reuse its name in a subsequent business. Being involved in management Following the insolvent winding-up of their partnership under the Insolvent…
…Disclosure is necessary for the fair disposal of the claim to save costs… In Destiny Investments (1993) Ltd v TH Holdings Ltd shareholders in a joint venture company have been granted an order requiring auditors to disclose documents to enable a valuation to be carried out. The joint venture company was formed for the purpose…
From 6 April 2016 every LLP registered in England and Wales must keep a Register of People with Significant Control (PSC). Failure to do so or to comply with the other requirements of the regulations will be a criminal offence. The significant control information will have to be filed at Companies House annually, and the…
It has become increasingly common for professional practices to find themselves in the position of having to recover substantial debts owed to the business by their partners or members. Scenarios that sometimes arise are:
LLP members might be entitled to protection under the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations 2006 (SI 2006/246) (TUPE). This consideration is at least in part prompted by the outcome of the recent Bates van Winkelhof case in the Supreme Court.
On an appeal in the case of Dhillon v Sandhu (2014 WL 5411909) His Honour Judge Hodge QC (sitting as a High Court Judge) has affirmed the application of sanctions imposed by an unless order made by Chief Master Marsh in the course of the taking of a partnership account. The judgment gives guidance as…
There are many circumstances in which an LLP member can end up with personal liability for either individual liabilities of the LLP or a share of the LLP’s losses over a particular period. This article examines just a couple of related examples as to how LLP members can end up bearing very substantial LLP losses….
…an historic rock and roll theme… In the case of Achom v Lalic [2014] the claimants (for whom I acted) had reached an understanding with the defendants whereby the defendants would acquire night club premises in Mayfair and the parties would together develop those premises into an exclusive night club with an historic rock and…
… most LLP members are entitled to a number of rights and protections … The Supreme Court has handed down judgment in favour of Ms van Winkelhof in the case of Clyde & Co LLP v Bates van Winkelhof, finding that she was a “worker” within the meaning of section 230(3) of the Employment Rights…
“… The trial judge was entitled to order separate accounts for diversion of profits and for dissolution …” The Court of Appeal yesterday confirmed an award of an interim payment against a partner prior to the taking of a dissolution account. In Mukerjee v Sen (unreported at first instance so far as I am aware)…
… The Judge considered whether it could argued that in all of the circumstances there was an implied contract between the members of the LLP and the insurers … In Zeckler v Assigned Risk Pool Manager Capita Commercial Services Ltd (reported on Westlaw) the High Court has allowed an appeal by a solicitor from an…
“… such a member cannot bring a whistleblowing claim (and would also be deprived of part-timer and equal pay remedies) …” In a previous post I commented on the case of Bates van Winkelhof v Clyde & Co in which the Employment Appeal Tribunal found that an LLP member was a “worker” within the meaning…
“… any partner or member who agrees to devote their full time and attention to the practice may well be a “worker” …” The case of Bates van Winkelhof v Clyde & Co in the Employment Appeal Tribunal (“EAT”) has made new law, answering the question: can an equity member of an LLP be a…
“… if the answer to any of these questions is, “No,” there may be a problem …” Following the Supreme Court judgment in Seldon, how do professional practices quickly determine whether or not they should be taking advice on their current partner or LLP member retirement provisions, with a view to minimising the risk of…
“… In these difficult times, in which many professional practices are facing potential or actual insolvency, it is important for “partners” to know what liabilities they face …” Last week’s Court of Appeal judgment in the case of Tiffin v Lester Aldridge LLP [2012] EWCA Civ 35 has brought more certainty to the frequently arising…
“… Most UK professional practices operate a system of inherently discriminatory compulsory retirement of partners at a fixed age, regardless of ability or performance, on the assumption that this is legally justified …” The case of Seldon v Clarkson Wright & Jakes is due to be heard by the Supreme Court on 17 January 2012…
“… The classic example that is often given is where a firm has contracted to build a bridge, and dissolution occurs when only half of the bridge has been built …” The recent case of Boghani v Nathoo [2011] EWHC 2101 (Ch) (judgment 2 August 2011) is a useful modern authority relating to the obligation…
The recent case of Eaton v Caulfield & others (an unfair prejudice petition brought under section 994 of the Companies Act 2006, coupled with a just and equitable winding up petition under section 122(1)(g) of the Insolvency Act 1986) highlights the difficulties faced by LLP members who do not have an LLP members’ agreement setting out their…
Partnership dissolution FAQs: What is dissolution? In the partnership context, “dissolution” describes both an event and a process : Continue Reading
“… while nobody sympathises with a money-launderer or other criminal, not only is there the possibility of a damages claim from a client, but also regulatory sanctions in addition …” Solicitors could inadvertently breach their obligations to certain clients by allowing their Solicitors Accounts Rules (SAR) auditors to view those clients’ files. Solicitors and other…
… most conduct that would have been sufficient to justify a discrimination or sexual harassment claim may well be oppressive and unacceptable and cause anxiety, alarm or distress …It is quite a common occurrence these days to find at the first meeting with a client that he or she has a perfectly good discrimination claim…
“… If someone is completing on Friday it does not help them if their solicitor ceases to practise on Thursday …” Some legal practices are only now, with one week to go, receiving premium quotes for their 1 October 2010 professional indemnity insurance renewal. It is nail-biting for them as they may have only one quote – it is…
… It is possible inadvertently to throw away these defences in the course of the process leading up to administration, a PVA and/or IVAs … This article describes the run-up to a professional partnership insolvency, and the choices faced by the partners who control the partnership. It then goes on to identify particular issues faced…
“… after a few hours of tight-lipped civility, one or other of the parties … cannot stop himself telling the other party what he really thinks …” There are a number of factors which distinguish partnership disputes from other types of commercial dispute. In consequence, different methods are sometimes required to achieve settlement. In this…
“… the income of the firm may well diminish and/or partners may not account fully or at all for accrued WIP …” Unless there is an express agreement between partners permitting retirement, no partner can retire from a partnership at will. The only way to bring about termination of the relationship is for one or…
“… the conviction that a partnership will last forever in sickness or in health, for richer or poorer, may fade quickly …” As is well known, under certain Middle Eastern legal systems a husband can divorce his wife by uttering, “I divorce thee” three times in her presence. In contrast, in a partnership at will…
“… Possession being nine-tenths of the law, a partner/member in this position may have to sue to recover his capital …” A worrying trend has been emerging. It has become much more common for partners and LLP members leaving professional practices to have difficulty extracting their capital. Typically professional practice governing agreements provide for capital…
“… how beneficial will consolidation into fewer, larger entities be for consumers? …” A great deal of time and money have been spent preparing for the arrival of Alternative Business Structures (ABS) in October 2011. The 2004 Clementi Report led the Ministry of Justice to formulate and pilot the Legal Services Bill through Parliament, and it passed into…
Please note: this post is now out of date following subsequent tax legislation and case law. “… At the outset he has been lulled into a false sense of security, and may consider himself to be the victim of a scam …” Lawyers and accountants have been very creative in their use of LLPs. But…
“… Typically the senior partner becomes complacent about the fabulous hand of cards that life has dealt him and starts to presume that he can do no wrong …” It may come as no surprise that amongst professional practices that have no provision in their partnership deed for regular senior partner elections, an unusually high proportion…
… The majority of professional practices are woefully deficient in detecting the “virus” at the point of introducing it/him into the practice … Last month I chaired an Association of Partnership Practitioners workshop on “Rogue Partners”. What was striking was how many members attended (well over 100 leading partnership practitioners) and the intense interest in the…
…Recessions bring out the worst in people… A recession has a way of exposing weaknesses in legal drafting. As practices try to respond to the economic climate, management teams consult the fine print of their partnership deed or LLP members’ agreement, and may find it wanting. This article describes and explains the importance of a…
“… the number of insureds under a practice’s professional indemnity insurance can easily double every fifteen or so years …” (First published in the Law Society Gazette on 20 August 2009) Last year a letter dropped though the door of numerous former employees of Merricks LLP, putting them on notice that if certain of the…
“… An intending purchaser who is aware of the firm’s difficulties should not purchase the firm from the partners, even if no winding-up or bankruptcy petitions have been presented …” (First published in the Law Society Gazette on 2 August 2007) Partners of an insolvent law firm cannot continue to practice indefinitely. Leaving aside that…
… By the time creditors are negotiating terms with partners the firm may have ceased to trade, and the partners may have gone their separate ways … (This article was first published in the Law Society Gazette on 21 June 2007) When a firm fails, major creditors are often prepared to agree to limit each…
If you’d like to discuss your situation on a confidential, no obligation basis, please contact me.
